Revise employee disciplinary hearing rules to prevent conflicts of interest
In Plain English
Skelly hearings let city employees challenge disciplinary actions before they take effect. Current rules allow department heads to oversee hearings for their own staff, creating potential bias. The new rules require neutral hearing officers from outside the employee's department. The city also cannot hire outside lawyers unless the employee has their own attorney.
Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.
Votes
Direct staff to begin the meet and confer process with the appropriate bargaining units with the intention of revising the Skelly process as recommended unless the employee who is the subject of the Skelly meeting requested their department head to serve as hearing officer
6 to 1
Why This Vote Matters
The council voted 6-1 to direct staff to negotiate changes to employee disciplinary hearings with city worker unions, with Councilmember Butt dissenting. Under the proposed reforms, when city employees challenge disciplinary actions, they would get a neutral hearing officer from outside their department instead of potentially having their own boss oversee the process. The changes would also prevent the city from hiring outside attorneys unless the employee brings their own lawyer, except when an employee specifically requests their department head conduct the hearing. This marks a rare departure from the council's typical unanimous support for personnel matters, as most members have voted yes on nearly every personnel item in recent meetings.
Auto-generated context. Source: official meeting records.
Other motions
Accept the first part of the main motion but not the second part regarding legal representation
FailedSimilar Discussions
5 related items found by meaning
Change process for employee disciplinary hearings involving department heads
Receive report on employee termination appeal process
Receive report on employee termination appeal process
Appoint confidential investigative and appeals officer
Adopt rules for how city negotiates with employee unions
The Story So Far
10 prior discussions on this topic
Meet privately with union negotiators to discuss employee contracts
Meet privately with union representatives to discuss employee contracts
Approve new 3-year contract with firefighters union covering wages and benefits
Approve hiring temporary fire department supervisors and add other city positions
Receive presentation on Rent Board staffing levels and recruitment
Investment and Cash Balance Report, Monthly Overtime Reports, Documentary Transfer Tax Report, and Other Post-Employment Benefits (OPEB) and Pension Report for the month of April 2026
Annual Public Hearing on Vacancies
Amendments to Position Control List
CONFERENCE WITH LABOR NEGOTIATORS (Government Code Section 54957.6)
23rd Street Ciclovía Pilot Project