Tuesday, April 2, 2019

Presiding: Mayor Thomas K. Butt · Called to order: 6:41 p.m. · 7 items · 24 votes · 33 public comments

What happened

  • Rejected Catherine Montalbo's appointment to Citizens Police Review Commission 5-2 (Bates, Butt dissenting).
  • Approved two T-Mobile cell tower appeals at Downer Avenue and Garvin Avenue locations.
  • Approved changing Citizens Police Review Commission name to Community Police Review Commission.
  • Approved urging Congress to pass national carbon fee and dividend law.
  • Approved 19 routine items including $333,000 playground equipment and $68,000 Ford trucks.

Auto-generated summary from agenda items and vote records

View official: Minutes

Attendance

Demnlus Johnson III(Present)
Eduardo Martinez(Present)
Jael Myrick(Present)
Melvin Willis(Present)
Ben Choi(Present)
Tom Butt(Present)
Nat Bates(Present)
7 substantive items · 19 consent

Appointments(1 item)

Appoint Catherine Montalbo to Citizens Police Review Commission

2-5Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The Citizens Police Review Commission investigates complaints against police officers and reviews use-of-force incidents. This appointment fills seat #5 on the 7-member commission. Commission members serve 2-year volunteer terms and meet monthly to provide civilian oversight of police conduct.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

To approve appointment of Catherine Montalbo with understanding that next City Council meeting would include other two CPRC nominees (Christopher Whitmore and Armond Lee)

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Mayor Butt
Failed

2 to 5

Thomas K. ButtAye
Nathaniel BatesAye
Demnlus Johnson IIINay
Eduardo MartinezNay
Jael MyrickNay
Melvin WillisNay
Ben ChoiNay

Governance(3 items)

Urge Congress to pass national carbon fee and dividend law

Environmental Justice

In Plain English

The Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act would put a fee on fossil fuels and return the money to Americans as monthly payments. The law aims to reduce carbon emissions by making clean energy cheaper than fossil fuels. Richmond joins other cities asking Congress to pass this national climate policy.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Passed

Update garbage collection rates and contamination fees

Environmental Justice

In Plain English

The city sets rates that garbage companies can charge residents for weekly pickup service. Current rates were last updated several years ago. If approved, new rates will include higher fees when residents put wrong items in recycling or yard waste bins.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve first reading of ordinance and lay over for two weeks for second reading

Moved by: Councilmember WillisSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

7 to 0

Thomas K. ButtAye
Nathaniel BatesAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye

Change Citizens Police Review Commission name to Community Police Review Commission

Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The city wants to rename the board that reviews police complaints and investigations. The Citizens Police Review Commission would become the Community Police Review Commission. This is the first of two required votes to make the name change official.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve first reading of ordinance and lay over for two weeks for second reading

Moved by: Councilmember WillisSeconded by: Councilmember Johnson
Passed

7 to 0

Thomas K. ButtAye
Nathaniel BatesAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye

Zoning(3 items)

Deny T-Mobile appeal to install small cell tower at 2100 Grant Avenue

T-Mobile Cell Tower Appeal

In Plain English

T-Mobile wants to install a small wireless antenna on Grant Avenue but the planning commission rejected their permit application. The company appealed that decision to the city council. If the council upholds the planning commission's decision, T-Mobile cannot build the cell tower at this location.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Decide appeal of approved T-Mobile cell tower at 2732 Downer Avenue

T-Mobile Cell Tower

In Plain English

The city planning department already approved T-Mobile's request to install a small cell tower at 2732 Downer Avenue. Someone appealed that decision to the city council. If the council upholds the appeal, T-Mobile cannot build the tower.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Uphold the Planning Commission's decision and deny said application (PLN18-128)

Moved by: Councilmember WillisSeconded by: Councilmember Martinez
Passed

5 to 0

Thomas K. ButtAye
Nathaniel BatesAbstain
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAbstain
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye

Decide appeal of T-Mobile cell tower permit at 2901 Garvin Avenue

T-Mobile Cell Site

In Plain English

T-Mobile wants to install a small cell tower at 2901 Garvin Avenue but someone appealed the planning approval. The city planning department already approved the permit for the wireless equipment. The council now decides whether to uphold the appeal and block the tower or reject the appeal and let T-Mobile proceed.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Uphold the Planning Commission's decision and deny said application (PLN18-130)

Moved by: Councilmember WillisSeconded by: Councilmember Martinez
Passed

6 to 0

Thomas K. ButtAye
Nathaniel BatesAbstain
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye

Approved as a group without individual discussion.